Thoughts on the critique

C3's post on the critique is right. The way the judges critiqued work wasn't constructive at all. I saw C3's design and loved it - along with many others - and thought that what the judges said seemed to be their personal opinions on the design, calling it a Bill Henson. This "personal critique" also came up when my group was critiqued. They called it modernist among other things. I want to know what is wrong if it looks a bit modernist - it was a very successful style for many iconic architects.